Código de Processo Penal Comentado | Flavio Meirelles Medeiros

Article 15 CPP – Minor Accused

Contribua com a manutenção deste site, faça um pix para [email protected].

Art. 15. If the accused is a minor, he will be appointed guardian by the  police authority.

Indication of the minor. Curator

https://youtube.com/watch?v=tX65n594Kk8%3Ffeature%3Doembed

Minor:  The reference made in the device is to minors under 21 and over 18 years old, as minors under 18 years old are subject to specific legislation ( Law n. 8069, of 7.13.90 – Statute of Children and Adolescents ).

Device devoid of effect:  Today, in view of the provisions of article 5 of the new Civil Code, according to which  minority ceases at the age of eighteen, when the person is qualified to practice all acts of civil life, it  is understood without any effect the device now under examination. Incidentally,  Law No. 10,792, of 12.1.2003,  revoked  Article 194 , which prescribed: “if the accused is a minor, the interrogation will be carried out in the presence of a curator” .

Curator and non-imputable:  There remains the need for the non-imputable to be assisted by a curator. The appointment should preferably fall to someone trusted by the accused. It could be a relative. It can also be the defender.

Role of the curator:  Mere appointment is not enough. The curator must effectively assist the investigated person, that is to say, be present during his/her testimony and participate in all acts in which the presence of the investigated person becomes necessary.

Inquiry of the curator in the Judiciary:  The curator has the right to remain silent if he is called to testify in the course of the procedural instruction. He was appointed to act as guardian of interests in favor of the accused, therefore having a duty to keep secret ( article 207 ).

Doctrine

Lidiana Figuerêdo Martins Pinheiro:  The international protection of refugee children’s rights  repositorio.ul.pt. 2015

Paulo Vasconcelos Jacobina:  Criminal law of madness: security measure and psychiatric reform .  app.uff.br

Sara Cristina Escalhão Gomes:   The Protection of Street Children in International Law  repositorio.ul.pt. 216

Taís Schilling Ferraz:  The importance of working with facts and projecting consequences . Conjure

Jurisprudence

Failure to appoint a curator in the inquiry :  It does not matter in nullity of the process (RJTJRS 107/153; TJRS – Ap. 684039209; TJRS – HC 684022692).

Prosecution’s Right to Name Trustee as Witness :  The prosecution does not have the right to call trustee as a witness. Curatela is the institute created for a curated benefit (RT 643/320).

Legality of maintaining a socio-educational measure of hospitalization even with a favorable opinion:  The maintenance of a socio-educational measure of hospitalization imposed on the appellant does not constitute manifest illegality or teratology, even if there is a favorable opinion of the interdisciplinary team (RHC 126.205, rel. Min. Rosa Weber, judgment on 3/24/2015, judgment published in the DJE of 4/15/2015 – Bulletin 779, First Panel).

Precedents

Precedent 605 of the STJ. Age of majority :   The age of majority does not interfere with the investigation of an offense or the applicability of an ongoing socio-educational measure, including probation, while the age of 21 is not reached (Third Section, approved on 03/14/2018, DJe 03/19/2018 – Newsletter n. 620).

End

PreviousPREVIOUSArticle 14-A – Investigated police officer

NEXTArticle 16 CPP – Return of the SurveyNext

Contribute with your comment

Logged in as Flavio Meirelles Medeiros. Edit your profile . To go out? Required fields are marked with *

Comment * 

Notify me via e-mail if anyone answers my comment.

Fim

Contribua com seu comentário

O seu endereço de e-mail não será publicado. Campos obrigatórios são marcados com *

Summary